A Tale of Two Palms: How Close Is Too Close in Trademark Law?

POSTED BY‍ ‍Joy Durand


In January 2026, the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office sustained an opposition and refused registration of GOLD PALM for wine, finding it likely to be confused with the registered mark SILVER PALM. (Jackson Family Farms, LLC v. Fairweather, Opposition No. 91291000 (TTAB Jan. 30, 2026) (nonprecedential).) The lesson for any business is simple: your brand doesn't have to be identical to another's to be too close under trademark law.

The dispute itself was straightforward. The applicant applied to register GOLD PALM for wine and other wine-based beverages. Jackson Family Farms already held two federal registrations for SILVER PALM, one for wine and one for alcoholic beverages except beers, and opposed on the ground that the GOLD PALM mark was likely to be confused with its own. Because those registrations were in the record and unchallenged, the case turned on a single question: likelihood of confusion.

One of the principal factors in determining likelihood of confusion is the similarity of the marks. Yes, "gold" and "silver" look and sound different, but both marks shared the identical term PALM. Here is the twist that trips up a lot of brand owners: the difference in metals did not save the junior mark. If anything, it hurt. Gold and silver are classic tiers of quality, from Olympic medals to wine-competition awards, and the Board credited evidence that wine buyers understand them that way. A shopper who already knows SILVER PALM could easily read GOLD PALM as the same winery's higher-end line.

While the applicant argued that PALM is weak in the wine world and that a color-plus-object naming convention lets consumers tell such brands apart, the Board was not persuaded. The Board called the record of other uses of “PALM” a far cry from the evidence that has shown a term to be weak in other cases. With the goods identical and the marks confusingly similar, the opposition was sustained.

There are lessons here for anyone who owns a brand or is about to choose one. The best time to catch a conflict is before launch, through a full availability search, long before labels are printed and distributors are lined up. Swapping one color or adjective for another may not be a safe harbor when the shared word is identical.

A trademark is a valuable business asset at every stage: when you launch, a clearance search can spare you a costly rebrand; when you extend a line, it can tell you whether a new name is really distinct; and when you are established, registration and enforcement give you the right to keep a look-alike off the register.



For help clearing, registering, or enforcing a trademark, or navigating an opposition or cancellation before the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, reach out to Joy Durand and DP&F’s Intellectual Property team.

Disclaimer: DP&F represented Jackson Family Farms in this opposition. Every matter turns on its own facts, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.


ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Joy Durand is an Intellectual Property attorney whose practice focuses on developing and managing U.S. and international trademark portfolios, including trademark clearance, prosecution of applications before the United States Patent and Trademark Office, and enforcement. She represents clients in federal court and before the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, where she has obtained favorable judgments in opposition and cancellation proceedings for clients across numerous industries, including alcoholic beverages, food, consumer products, construction, and technology (including software and AI).

Joy earned her J.D. from the University of San Francisco School of Law, where she served as Managing Director of the Moot Court Board and received CALI Awards for Excellence in Alternative Dispute Resolution and Civil Procedure II. Joy earned her B.S. from Saint Mary's College of California, and she also has an M.B.A. from Sonoma State University.

Next
Next

California Secretary of State User Access Update